Good news and upbeat local happenings in Sarasota
Main Street Creamery

Main Street Creamery

Sweets & Treats in Sarasota

4.9 582 Google reviews

+1 941 361 20 461359 Main St, Sarasota, Florida 34236 · Main Street Merchants

Main Street CreameryMain Street Creamery, photo 2Main Street Creamery, photo 3Main Street Creamery, photo 4

Where to find them

1359 Main St, Sarasota, Florida 34236

Free newsletter

More of Sarasota in your inbox

Local news, new businesses and what's on from Sarasota Wire, once a week.

Get directionsOpen in Maps

About

"We remember the “good old days,” when families would go into town and visit the local ice cream parlor for a cone, a root beer float, or an old-fashioned milkshake. Those trips formed such fond memories for many of us. Those “good old days” are the inspiration behind the Main Street Creamery, a place in downtown Sarasota where you can eat locally made, nationally recognized ice cream from Yoder’s Southern Creamery, served with the small town charm of yesteryear’s ice cream parlor! Our joy is to be part of the memories that you and yours look back on with fondness. May these days be always remembered as some of your best “good old days.”

Amenities

From the business

  • Small business

Service options

  • Delivery
  • In-store shopping
  • Onsite services
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Popular for

  • Solo dining

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom

Offerings

  • Coffee

Dining options

  • Seating
  • Table service

Hours

Monday
12 to 10 PM
Tuesday
12 to 10 PM
Wednesday
12 to 10 PM
Thursday
12 to 10 PM
Friday
12 to 10 PM
Saturday
12 to 10 PM
Sunday
Closed

More Sweets & Treats in Good news and upbeat local happenings in Sarasota

The Fat Donkey Ice cream shop
Treat Yourself to Sweet Desserts and Delicious Ice Cream! Offering a Wide Variety of Ice Cream Combinations, there is something for everyone to love - Gluten Free, Non-Dairy, Vegan and No Sugar Added Options Available. Come and #DoItForTheDonk Today!
Great Heights Creamery Ice cream shop
At Great Heights Creamery, we create artisanal, small batch ice cream. We combine local, grass-fed dairy, cage-free eggs, and organic sugar to churn super-premium ice cream. Our goal is to create fun, interesting and unique flavors with the highest quality ingredients. We designed and built a custom ice cream cart that can be booked for all types of events including birthday parties and weddings. Email: hello@greatheightscreamery.com
Paleteria Y Neveria La Mexicana Ice cream shop
1303 N Washington Blvd Unit a
Mr. chamoy Ice cream shop
1900 N Washington Blvd
I Love Candy Ice Cream Ice cream shop
Discover the epitome of style and protection at Love Sunglasses, your premier destination for high-quality sunglasses in the heart of Sarasota, Florida. Located amidst the vibrant culture and sunny beaches of the Gulf Coast, our store offers an extensive selection of fashionable and functional eyewear for every taste and occasion. At Love Sunglasses, we pride ourselves on curating a diverse range of sunglasses from renowned brands and independent designers, ensuring you find the perfect pair to complement your lifestyle. Whether you're strolling along Siesta Key Beach, attending a cultural event in downtown Sarasota, or simply enjoying the sunny Florida weather!
Settimi's Gelato Ice cream shop
Artisan Gelato made on site
Gelato-go Bakery Sarasota Ice cream shop
321 John Ringling Blvd
Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge Ice cream shop
Kilwins is renowned for its hand-crafted chocolates, creamy fudge, caramel apples, brittle, and super-premium ice cream, all made with the finest ingredients. Kilwins has been making people happy since 1947, providing customers with warm, friendly service and a nostalgic confectionery experience. Customers can enjoy watching fudge being paddled on a marble table and caramel cooking in a copper kettle, all in an open kitchen setting.. Kilwins is truly "Sweet in every Sense since 1947."

Is this your business? Free, takes two minutes.

Sarasota Wire

© 2026 Sarasota Wire.

Sarasota Wire brings you the brighter side of Sarasota and the surrounding area — good news, funny local happenings, community wins, new openings, uplifting stories and useful things worth sharing.

© 2026 Sarasota Wire.